PhotobucketMy teens may not thank me for saying this on the web, out here where everyone can read it, but… they still read pictures books. Willingly and randomly.

At least on occasion.

It’s only been a few weeks since I packed up our shelves full of picture books. (I’m being optimistic about finding a place to move to.) But before I could pack them, I had the challenge of convincing the kids that 1. No, I am NOT getting rid of them, and 2. They really can live without them for a few months.)

Of course, as soon as I pack them up, a review arrives that makes me wish I hadn’t.

We received Before Five In A Row, a parent’s guide to enhancing storytime with relevant learning activities. Don’t take “activities” the wrong way – Before Five In A Row is not a curriculum. Consider it something akin to a tourism guide to picture books – with info about suggested places you might stop, and things you might want to consider while you’re there, but by no means a detailed itinerary that you’re expected to follow.

While Before Five In A Row was designed with 2-4 year olds in mind, the kids and I all felt that the age range could be extended by a year or two. Granted, Five in a Row books are also available that are geared toward the 5 and ups.

Wait, you say? What were we doing reviewing stuff for preschoolers when the youngest is 9?

Well, you see… all four of the kids have been preschoolers. And I’ve been mom to a preschooler. Four times, in fact. And the kids have a younger half-sister and step-sister, and they’re [usually] pretty good at guessing what sort of things they like.

And it’s not like convincing them to read picture books was any challenge.

The most time-consuming part, for me at least, was searching for every single one of the 24 titles in the library system and requesting them. Since, silly me, I went and packed all the picture books.

Chances are, if you have your own picture book library, you already own a few of the titles. If not, or if, like me, they’re unavailable for some reason, there’s a good chance your local library will have most of them. (Every single title was owned by at least one of the two library systems here.)

Before Five In A Row has two distinct parts. There are 24 mini-studies in the first part. (And if you notice elsewhere that it says 23, I have no idea why; I counted, multiple times, and there really are 24 of them.)

Each mini-study is focused on one title. Activities are noted by subject area, yes – but these are readiness skills for that subject area. A suggested bible verse is included for each unit. Other topics include science, history, math, language, art, values, thinking skills, etc.

These aren’t the “sit-down, do work” sort of activities that you might have see in other preschool-targeted materials. Instead, this are intended to inject casual learning into everyday storytime. Many of the ideas here can be easily adapted to other books once you have the general idea down. It’s similar to discussing colors as the cars go by, or counting toys that have to be picked up, or naming body parts as you wash them in the bath. Normal, natural, everyday learning.

The second part of the book, subtitled “Parent’s Treasury of Creative Ideas for Learning Readiness” is exactly that. A collection of fun, flexible tools to integrate readiness into your daily routine. Categories include reading readiness, large and small motor skills, activities at bathtime, in the kitchen or the store, or learning through toys and the visual arts. These pages will make a huge addition to your teaching moment toolbox, don’t overlook them!

Just in case it isn’t obvious – this book is not just for homeschoolers. Even if you have no intention of teaching your children at home once they have reached school age, you and your child can benefit from this book. Encouraging reading and interaction with books will increase the likelihood that your child will do well in school, and that’s something that every involved parent should desire to stimulate.

Even though mine are past the target age for this book, I’m finding ways I can adapt the info to fit me and my kids . I really wish I’d found it when the kids were younger. If I someday I have another preschooler, you can bet this book will be on my shelf.

For more information about Before Five in a Row, check out this page on Five in A Row’s (FIAR) website. Before Five In A Row is a 150-page, black-and white, illustrated, large-format paperback book, available from Rainbow Resource. There are three subsequent titles in the series: Five In A Row (4 volumes), Beyond Five In A Row (4 volumes, plus a supplement), and Above and Beyond Five In A Row. Sample lessons for the later books are also available on the website, along with a forum where parents can ask questions and interact with others who are using Five In A Row materials.

To see what other crew members had to say about this product, check out the TOS Homeschool Crew blog post, Five In A Row.

**I received this product for free as a member of the 2011-12 The Old Schoolhouse Homeschool Crew so that I could provide you with an honest review of it by our family.**

 

Photobucket

I’m ALWAYS  on the lookout for new science materials. Something new, something different, something fun, something simple, etc. So I’m at least somewhat familiar with the main science curricula out there created for homeschoolers.

We were recently sent an issue of Science Weekly to review. Each edition of Science Weekly is available in six different levels, individualized for grades K-6. (The issue for 5th/6th grade is the same.) The theme of the issue was Fractions – not exactly your typical science topic, but useful, since so many science projects do require an understanding of fractions for measuring.

I was pleasantly surprised to see how much effort had been put into adapting each level to be appropriate for the age group. The changes in word difficulty, depth of detail, and work required are impressively detailed – these aren’t token changes. To examine the issues for yourself and see what I’m talking about, download samples of the Coral Reefs edition here. Teacher’s notes for each level, with supplemental information and answer keys, are also available.

Subjects covered seem random but full of intriguing variety. For the 2010-11 school year, topics covered include: Pulleys, Cats, The Flu, Glass, Fractions, Composting, The Science of Movies, The Science of Money, Scuba Diving, Poisonous Animals, Caves, Teeth, Deserts, Green Buildings, The Moon.

All in all, Science Weekly would make a fun science supplement for grade schoolers, and Level E could possibly be adapted to interest older students, especially if working alongside younger students. Lab projects are different in each level, so it would be possible to combine and extend the length of each unit.

However – there are a couple things that concern me. Science Weekly’s website describes science weekly as a supplement for public school science – but in emails sent to homeschoolers, it was implied that it would be a more comprehensive curriculum then what they are currently using.

Quotes from the email:

Science Weekly offers an interdisciplinary and inquiry approach to enhance the homeschool teacher’s knowledge and skills in teaching science and literacy.

I’d have to say that this statement might be accurate – but Science Weekly comes across more like a science reader – reading practice on a science topic – then an actual science curriculum. Which might be all well and good for a public school… but most homeschoolers expect actual curriculum. Instead, these are like light unit studies.

Another quote:

Science Weekly is an equitable solution that guarantees each homeschooler an exposure to a body of organized instruction in Science.

Ouch. Several quibbles with this statement. It’s 15 light unit studies per year, not even enough to fill half the weeks in a short school year. It’s also very randomly distributed subjects. It’s not comprehensive enough to “solve” anything, in my opinion, nor is there anyway it could be considered very “organized”.

As for “equitable”… I’m not even sure what they intended to say with that phrase. Overall, it’s not an email that’s likely to win homeschool fans, and I’d definitely suggest that they run further adwriting past a homeschooler or two before sending it out. Again, this is a publication created for and marketed to public schools, which probably explains the awkwardness.

Also a bit awkward: the pricing scale. For classrooms, pricing is currently $4.95 per student per year – that’s with a 20 student minimum. Teaching Notes are free for orders with over 25 student copies. For individual copies, a year’s subscription is $19.95… rather highly priced, in my opinion, for one 11×17 sheet, folded in half, per issue, 15 times a year.

Science Weekly could be a fantastic, fun, spontaneous supplement for the homeschool market – but due to the current sales and pricing structure, I just can’t wholeheartedly recommend it. The price is just too high to make it a good value.

What I’d really love to see is for Science Weekly to take into consideration that the homeschool market is a totally different ballgame then public schools, and re-think it’s individual offerings. This is how I’d change it:

  • Sell subscriptions that include all the levels, plus the teacher’s notes. Make it one reasonable rate. $120 per year for what works out to 105 sheets of 11×7 copy paper, counting the teacher’s notes, isn’t something anyone is going to consider acceptable.
  • Better yet, they’ve already made a step into online issues and downloadable pdfs with their “new interactive format“. Offer a subscription to this format at a rate comparable to competitors, and homeschoolers will sign up.
  • Or take it even further – this is what I’d see as ideal. Sell subscriptions to upcoming years as ebooks. Offer past years in year-bundles or as individual titles. Homeschoolers, as a rule, LOVE unit studies, especially for science, and these are perfect. Let us pick and choose which issues – or all issues – and make some money off your backlist at the same time! 2010-11 is Volume 27. The idea of 26 more years worth of issues just sitting around when they could easily sell as $3-5 ebooks (with all levels and teacher’s notes)… well, I just can’t believe they haven’t already done it.

I’m actually considering purchasing a subscription for a year, of the most challenging level, E. I think we could easily adapt it for the kids next year. But if I had several gradeschoolers that I needed different levels for – probably wouldn’t happen.

To sum it all up: I’m not fond of the marketing and pricing, but because it IS a great product, I’d really like to see some improvements made in those areas.

To see what other crew members had to say about this product, check out the TOS Homeschool Crew blog post, Science Weekly.

**I received this product for free as a member of the 2010-11 The Old Schoolhouse Homeschool Crew so that I could provide you with an honest review of it by our family.**

 

Photobucket

Zeezok’s Z-Guides to the Movies are in-depth film studies that enhance learning by putting each film into the proper historical and social context. There are nearly 30 titles currently available, and more are planned.

Each unit study is available in ebook form on CD. Some, but not all, titles are also available as instant downloads – eventually, all will be. (See the list at the end of the post for titles available.)

I let the kids choose the movie, and we received The Adventures of Robin Hood study guide. It was easiest for us to obtain the movie via Netflix. (I’m told that all movies used for z-guides are available through Netflix.) Other options might be your local library or video rental store, though Zeezok also sells them if you desire to purchase. The kids were surprised at how enjoyable they found the movie. The discussion that ensued wandered into the realms of changing technology,  along with how some movies (or books or music) can be so well-done that they become classics that are enjoyed by many generations.

Each study includes a week-long suggested schedule to use if desired. We actually stretched it out over a time period closer to a month. I’m not much of a TV person – I don’t think I could stand to go through all the activities and re-watching as needed in just one week!

The ebook is 32 pages, with slight color accents, but easy to read when printed in black and white. (I only print in color if I absolutely must – ink lasts much longer that way. Initially, I intended to have Tiger and Chef, my middle and high-schooler, answer the questions on paper, so I printed out copies of the activity pages for each of them. It didn’t work out that way. We found it much more realistic to simply use the questions as discussion questions. That allowed my younger two students to also participate fully, because I could more easily explain questions and terms that they did not understand. It also made for a much better discussion group, as five creates a much more vibrant discussion then just three. (And since in this house, when the TV goes on, they all watch, it makes a lot more sense to include them in the educational part, too.)

Preparation, other then obtaining and previewing the movie (if desired), is minimal – skim the pages and decide if you want to use the print method, the discussion method, or a combination of the two.

It’s easily adaptable to a variety of learning styles, and each study even includes some type of “hands-on” activity for the kinesthetic learner. Other activities include various topical discussion questions, some kind of “fun page” (ours had a word search),

A note about ratings, movies, and appropriateness:

Many of the movies used were creating before the ratings system was put into place. When you look for rating information, you may find it blank or NR. A representative from Zeezok assured me that they have done their best to carefully choose movies that will be acceptable to the widest range of families. Due to individual preferences, I’d recommend that you do your own research if you have questions. IMDB has a parental guide/ content advisory section, or check your favorite movie ratings site. (Wikipedia might also be useful – sometimes controversies are noted there.)

Also – one of the main benefits of these guides is that they give you a way to discuss tough subject matter with your children. These movies are set in a different time and place then the world we live in. It can be difficult to imagine a world so different in many respects from our own, and the movies are a visual, immersive window into that former reality. Explaining what racial prejudice is in dry facts, that’s one thing. Showing, visually, with characters that they can identify with, and emotions and consequences of that prejudice; that leads to a depth of understanding that can only be eclipsed by actually having lived through it.

And that’s one of the things we’re trying so hard to teach our children, isn’t it? To learn from the mistakes of the past so they are not doomed to repeat them.

Thoughts on value:

Z-Guides are $12.99 each. I’d consider this a bit steep for a 32-page ebook, though the questions truly are impressive. When purchasing on CD, shipping and handling adds another $5.95 – bringing the total to just under $19. Definitely not going to happen around here on a weekly basis. I also tend to be annoyed with ebooks that are the same price instant download as shipped on CD – the minimal overhead, should, in my opinion, give at least a slight discount. Especially when the physical product does not allow resell.

However, if you spread the use out over a month, more like we did, it brings the price to a much more budget-friendly range, and sticking to instant downloads, too, will help. As the material is quite good, we’ll likely purchase other titles, though the price will make it occasional use, rather then regular. (Ideally, I’d like to see the instant download in the $5-8 range – and would really prefer it to be available through my favorite homeschool e-curriculum site, just to simplify things, rather then the individual publisher’s page.)

Titles (with topics covered) currently available include:

12 Angry Men - U.S. Government, Judicial Procedures, Power of Observation, Capital Punishment, Social Justice
A Man for All Seasons - Tudor English History, Henry VIII, Sir Thomas More, Separation of Church and State, Character Quality of Keeping Your Word
A Tale of Two Cities - French Revolution, 18th Century European History, Consequences of Revenge, Sacrificial Love
Amazing Grace - 18th Century British History, Abolition of Slavery, William Wilberforce, Civic Responsibility
Ben-Hur - Roman Empire, History of Palestine, Friendships, Consequences of Hatred

Cromwell - English History, English Civil War, Oliver Cromwell, Principles of Government
Driving Miss Daisy - Post-World War II U.S. History, Personal Relationships, Race Relationships, Discrimination
Father Goose - World War II in the Pacific, Interpersonal Relationships, Honesty
Flyboys - World War I, Facing Uncertainty / Death, Racial Prejudice, Aeronautics
Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner - Race Relations, Interracial Marriage, Parent-Child Relationships

Inherit the Wind - The Roaring Twenties 1925, Political Advertising
Jason and the Argonauts - Ancient Greek history, Greek Mythology, Consequences of Lying, Consequences of Disobedience
Johnny Tremain - Events Leading Up To The American Revolution, Dealing with False Accusations, Handling Personal Disappointment, Self-Sacrifice for the Good of the Nation
Kit Kittredge - The Great Depression, Hobo Life, Journalism
Knights of the Round Table - Medieval England, Character Development, Friendship, Consequences of Forbidden Love, Leadership Qualities

Les Miserables - Love, Forgiveness, Mercy, Consequences of a Vengeful Spirit, Random Acts of Kindness, Parenting
Mr. Smith Goes to Washington - U.S. Government, Judicial Procedures, Power of Observation, Capital Punishment, Social Justice
My Side of the Mountain - Natural Science, Henry David Thoreau, Survival Skills
One Night with the King - Ancient Persian History, Ancient Israel History, Loyalty, Results of Excessive Pride and Desire for Revenge, God’s Providence
Scarlet Pimpernel - French Revolution, Preservation of Innocent Life, Civil Disobedience

Sergeant York - Civil War, Conquering Your Fears, Psychology of War, Consequences of Lying
The Adventures of Robin Hood - Medieval English history, Ethnic Conflict, Chivalry, Civil Disobedience
The Boy in the Striped Pajamas - Germany in World War II (1942-1944), Concentration Camps, Consequences of Lying, Friendships and Forgiveness, Impact of Propaganda
The Count of Monte Cristo - 19th Century France, Napoleon Bonaparte, Consequences of Lying and Scheming, Dealing with False Accusations, Anger and Revenge, Handling Wealth, Mentoring
The Hiding Place – World War II, Life in a German Concentration Camp, Forgiveness, Civil Disobedience

The Red Badge of Courage - Civil War, Conquering Your Fears, Psychology of War, Consequences of Lying
The Ten Commandments - Ancient Jewish History, Ancient Egyptian History, Forgiveness, Divine Providence, Egyptian Architecture
To Kill A Mockingbird - U.S. History Great Depression, Race Relations, Courtroom Procedures, Consequences of Lying

Z-Guides to the Movies may be purchased from Zeezok for $12.99 each.

To see what other crew members had to say about this product, check out the TOS Homeschool Crew blog post, Zeezok Publishing – Z-Guide to the Movies.

**I received this product for free as a member of the 2010-11 The Old Schoolhouse Homeschool Crew so that I could provide you with an honest review of it by our family.**

 

Photobucket

Kids ask the darnedest questions. I don’t think a week goes by without at least one of the kids coming to me with one of those totally off-the wall puzzlers. The kind that there’s just no answer for – except to admit, “I haven’t the faintest idea… but we could look it up.”

Thank God for the internet. Can’t quite imagine what homeschooling, or parenting, for that matter, was like before it. Simpler, I’m sure. But so less full of ANSWERS to all those impossible questions! (By the way, _can_ those orange and clove ball things be made with other kinds of fruit?)

If your family, like mine, thrives on searching out the answers to all those unique and wonderful questions, I’ve got just the unit study series to recommend to you.

This is Ana Lyze. She’s just even more curious then the rest of us, and she’s eager to share her research with your family.

The Curiosity Files are the pinnacle of weird and unusual. Forget unit studies on mundane things like inventions and plants and pets. Imagine the surprise on your kids’ face when you tell them,

“Today, we’re going to start learning about Quicksand.”

A Curiosity Files book is a reusable ebook with approximately 80 pages – print as many of the pages as you need. It’s in full color – but you can always print in grayscale if you’re in ink-saving mode.

You know how parents joke about telling kids to go play in the freeway? That’s how I actually announced to my kids which book we were reviewing – I told them I was going to let them play in Quicksand.

We learned about Quicksand and worked through activities that focused on math, spelling, vocabulary, handwriting, science experiments, geography, art, and hands-on activities. Also included were music jingles to jog the memory, plus recommended books and websites for further reading.

Especially in January and February, we need something to drag out of the rut – workbooks and drill and same old, blah blah blah – need something fun! Something different. Just to learn. Quicksand was perfect. The kids enjoyed it, we colored and mixed and explored.

Their only complaint? After asking what other books there were, I was quite firmly informed that I should have gotten ZOMBIE FIRE ANTS. Because they’re zombies. And bugs. What can I say? I have three boys and a tomboy. Zombies are always a win.

Ok, so you’re maybe you’re not an eclectic homeschooler, picking and choosing the curriculum that works for you and your child(ren), and adapting it to their needs. You don’t teach unit studies, using topics straight from the world around you to determine what math and science your students need to know. Maybe you’re a classical homeschooler, preferring that everything is straight from original sources. Maybe you’re by-the-book, straight-of-the-box, just keep everything simple sort.

I can hear you now. You’re thinking nope, unit studies just aren’t right for our family. There’d be tradeoffs. We’d lose time that we need for our core curriculum – and we have to use up the curriculum we’ve already planned out.

Aren’t you just the least bit curious? Wonder what it’s like teaching through a unit study, learning for the sake of knowledge, not just because it’s going to be on the test at the end of the week, or the end of the school year? Learning just because you’re curious, and want to know what and how and why?

Curiosity Files will work for you, too. There’s no long-term commitment, no this-will-take-a-semester lesson plans. Just a week, or two, or even a month, of pure curiosity satisfaction. When you feel like it.

With the Curiosity Files ebooks, the topics are outrageous. You won’t find dung-beetles or blue diamonds in your state mandated test, so you don’t have to stress over it, just enjoy the study with your kids and see how it goes.

Try one of these out. They’re not expensive. You can download one and be printing in moments – and rediscover, along with your children, learning for the sheer joy of it, with no other goal in mind, then simply answering “Why?”

There are currently nine Curiousity Files books.  Available titles are: Blue Diamond, Blue-Footed Booby, Cicada-Killing Wasp, Dung Beetle, MRSA, Puffer Fish, Quicksand, Red Tide, and Zombie Fire Ants.

For the best value, purchase the Curiosity Files in a downloadable ebook bundle for $46, or if you prefer to order a physical product, buy the  Curiosity Files on CD for $49. They’re also available individually at The Old Schoolhouse Store – check for current prices.

To see what other crew members had to say about this product, check out the TOS Homeschool Crew blog post, TOS – The Curiosity Files.


**I received this product for free as a member of the 2010-11 The Old Schoolhouse Homeschool Crew so that I could provide you with an honest review of it by our family.**

 

Photobucket

Travel the WorldThe Homeschool Crew has set sail, searching for great new products to share with other homeschoolers. Homeschool Crew members are provided with products for free in order to share them with you. You’ll always have my honest opinion, so jump on in and explore with me! Our first stop is at The Old Schoolhouse...

If you’re looking for a fun unit study on geography, the June 2010 module of the Schoolhouse Planner, Travel The World, might be the way to go. More of a general overview then an in-depth study, this activity-based ebook has 50 pages with a variety of materials, including worksheets, lapbook printables, maps, copywork, and a plethora of links.

Designed to be used by the whole family at once, most of the worksheets are appropriate for late grade school or middle school, though my older student enjoyed them due to the puzzle-style content. The “high school expansion” section could be also be used with younger children.

It’s economical: most printables are in black & white, so a copy can be made for each student, but the “text” portion of the book is in color, sometimes with multiple images per page, so we just printed one for everyone to share.

Additional items that will be helpful to have on hand:

  • Computer with internet access for kids to use for reference and game/quiz links
  • Globe or world maps
  • Geography book with regional description information
  • Encyclopedia

Activity rather then lesson-based, it’s very flexible; do each part straight through, or pick and choose, it’s up to you. I provided the kids with all the materials at once, and let them decide what order to work in. That spread resource use out enough that we didn’t have a line of children all stuck while waiting to use the same item, always a potential stumbling block in our house.

Adaptable to any learning or teaching style, it worked well for us with a bit of light guidance and direction. Mine are fairly comfortable with researching a given topic and finding information for lapbooks. I did find myself wishing that lapbook parts had been included specifically to go along with the vocabulary worksheets. Nowhere in the activities were the meanings of those words used or discussed, and we ended up creating our own booklets with that information.

An abundance of quality links; many were added to the kids’ resource and game bookmarks for future use. Some will provide the most benefit by returning occasionally over time.

Preparation time is minimal; printing materials and gathering resources. Teaching time will depend on the particular students involved, and could range from minimal with older students to intensive with younger students who aren’t able to effectively research yet.

Individual reactions: We enjoy unit studies, but this one was a bit more broad-spectrum then we’re used to. It highlights the main points of geography, which would work well as an introduction or a refresher, rather then for complete understanding. My older students felt the worksheets were “easy”, but still enjoyed participating, thanks to the puzzle-style worksheets. (And they’re always happy to do anything cut-and-paste or on the computer.) My detail-oriented, perfectionist 5th grader also caught an error on the fill-in-the-blanks page, #3, that none of his siblings did. That required some mom-intervention to figure out what the answer was actually supposed to be.

Don’t be mislead by the title - my initial expectation, was that the theme would be something “fluffy” related to summertime travel or vacation time, perhaps common places and activities that people go and do. Instead, I found a hefty amount of solid geography material with a wide selection of ideas to choose from.

Travel the World is may be purchased from The Old Schoolhouse for $7.95. New modules are available each month as add-ons to the Schoolhouse Planner, but it’s not necessary to have the planner to make use of the modules; each module is a stand-alone unit study.

To see what other crew members had to say about this product, check out the TOS Homeschool Crew blog post, TOS – Travel the World E-Book (June 2010).

**I received this product for free as a member of the 2010-11 The Old Schoolhouse Homeschool Crew so that I could provide you with an honest review of it by our family.**

June Module spread

© 2010 Tenacity Divine Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha